← ExitPart C · Exercise 2 — Defensive medicine and the cost of fear18:00

Part C · Exercise 2 — Defensive medicine and the cost of fear

OET · Reading

8 questions · 18 min

Part C · Long texts

In this part of the test, there is a text about an aspect of healthcare. For questions 1–8, choose the answer (a, b, c or d) which you think fits best according to the text.

Defensive medicine and the cost of fear

Ask a roomful of doctors whether they practise defensively and most will say no. Ask the same doctors what they did in last Friday's clinic and a different picture emerges. In a survey of 210 GPs across the Wren Valley district, 137 admitted that in the previous month they had ordered at least one test or referral mainly to protect themselves, not because the patient needed it. Defensive medicine comes in two kinds. The first adds things: the scan nobody needed, the follow-up that reassures the doctor more than the patient. The second takes things away: the awkward patient steered towards a colleague, the risky decision passed upwards. Both are driven by the same impulse, and it is not concern for the patient. The costs are easy to overlook because they are scattered. A man in his fifties with a backache, whom I will call Mr Sullivan, was sent for a scan that his history never justified. It found something harmless and incidental, and it took six months, three further appointments and a great many sleepless nights to establish that it was harmless. He was never angry, only puzzled, and he asked me, reasonably enough, why anyone had looked in the first place. Multiply Mr Sullivan by the several hundred scans our district requests each month and the bill is not only financial. Imaging departments stretched thin by requests that were never clinical in origin make everyone wait, including those with genuine reasons to be frightened. In Wren Valley the wait for a routine scan has now reached nine weeks. Critics will say that this is easy to write from the safety of a comfortable practice. Dr Amina Rahimi, who advises doctors facing complaints, has heard the argument many times and puts it with some force: nobody has ever been disciplined for ordering one test too many, but a missed diagnosis can end a career, and a doctor who feels that threat is not being irrational. I accept much of this. I have opened an envelope from a solicitor myself, and I remember the lurch in my stomach. Fear of that kind is not a character flaw; it is a reasonable response to an unreasonable system. Those who mock it have usually never been on the receiving end of it. Yet reasonable fear can still be a poor guide, because it is fixed on the wrong danger. Our practice at Ashby Green reviewed every complaint it received over five years: 31 in all. Only four concerned a delayed or missed diagnosis. Twenty-four were about the way the patient had been spoken to, and most of those turned on a version of the same sentence: nobody listened. We had been guarding the side door through which a handful of cases might come while the front entrance stood wide open. The patient who complains is far less often the one who was given too little investigation than the one who was given too little time. Better documentation is the usual remedy, and here the profession is divided. A thorough note is a double-edged sword. It protects the doctor who made a sound decision, but it also teaches a young doctor to write for the hostile reader who may one day appear rather than for the colleague who will see the patient next week. Notes now run to three screens, with a line for every complication that was discussed, and the registrars who write them know that nobody will read them until something goes wrong. Younger doctors absorb the lesson fastest. Chloe Nguyen, a registrar who trained with us last year, told me that at medical school she was taught to tolerate uncertainty and on the wards she was taught to document it. She said it lightly, but the distinction is not a light one. Tolerating uncertainty means staying with a patient through a few days of not knowing, saying plainly what to watch for and when to come back. Documenting it means making sure that, whatever happens, the record will show who was told what. The two can coincide. They often do not, and a registrar who has watched a colleague summoned to a hearing does not need telling which skill is the safer one to practise. A senior partner of mine used to say that the bravest sentence in general practice is ‘let us wait and see’. I have started to say it more often, and to write it down in full: what I expect, what would change my mind, when the patient should come back. It takes about a minute. I have noticed that patients rarely ask for the scan once they have heard the reasoning, and that the note reads rather well for any solicitor who might one day have to read it. Callum MacLeod is a GP partner at Ashby Green Surgery in Wren Valley and teaches communication skills to trainee doctors.
1

What is the main point of the first paragraph?

2

According to the second paragraph, what is one effect of unnecessary scans?

3

What is the writer's attitude to Dr Rahimi's argument in the third paragraph?

4

Why does the writer describe the review of complaints at Ashby Green?

5

In the fifth paragraph, the expression 'a double-edged sword' is used to stress that a thorough note

6

In the fifth paragraph, 'them' in 'who write them' refers to

7

What does Chloe Nguyen's remark in the sixth paragraph suggest?

8

What does the writer imply in the last paragraph?

Automated checks: item counts, answer keys, timing, and drug dose and unit style. — OET-READING-C-02

Answered 0 / 8