← ExitPart C · Exercise 1 — The ward round: who speaks, who listens18:00

Part C · Exercise 1 — The ward round: who speaks, who listens

OET · Reading

8 questions · 18 min

Part C · Long texts

In this part of the test, there is a text about an aspect of healthcare. For questions 1–8, choose the answer (a, b, c or d) which you think fits best according to the text.

The ward round: who speaks, who listens

Every morning at Oldtown Hospital the same small drama is staged at the foot of a hundred beds. A consultant arrives with a registrar and two junior doctors, and together they fan out in a loose semicircle around the patient. The nurse who has looked after that patient since seven o'clock is usually somewhere behind them, or at the edge, or not there at all because the drug round cannot wait. The conversation that follows is brisk, expert and, more often than not, conducted over the nurse's head. I stood in that gap for nineteen years before it occurred to me to measure it. When our ward sisters audited 120 rounds on four medical wards last spring, a nurse was asked a direct question in only 38 of them. This matters because the nurse is the one member of the team who has been in the room all night. That nurse knows that Mr Haddad refused his breakfast, that his daughter telephoned twice in the small hours, and that he was calmer on Tuesday than he is today. None of this appears on the observation chart. I am not describing a lapse of attention: good nurses notice a great deal precisely because they are not hunting for a diagnosis; they are watching a person. Rhys Jovanovic, a junior doctor on our wards, put it bluntly: he learns what the nurses know only when a bleep wakes him at three in the morning, and by then it has stopped being information and become a problem. Critics will say that a round is a clinical instrument, not a seminar. Dr Marek Kowalski, one of our consultants, makes the case without apology: with forty patients to see and a theatre list at noon, every extra voice is a minute taken from the last patient on the list. He has a point, and I have sat through enough three-hour rounds to remember the weariness. Nor can I pretend that a nurse is easily released from a bay of confused patients when a colleague has called in sick. The objection is a serious one. It is also, I have come to suspect, a very convenient one. Yet the arithmetic does not support it. For eight weeks, on two of our wards, the nurse responsible for each bay joined the doctors for a five-minute huddle before the round began. Each nurse was given two minutes to say what had changed overnight, and the doctors were asked only to listen. The rounds themselves ran, on average, three minutes longer. But the unplanned reviews called in the afternoon fell from twenty-two a week to fourteen, and the juniors stopped discovering at four o'clock that a patient had scarcely eaten for two days. Silence had not saved the time; it had merely borrowed it from the afternoon, at a punishing rate of interest. The patient is the other absent voice. Last winter I stood behind a round while a team discussed a woman in her eighties for four minutes, in the third person, as she lay between them. Afterwards Mrs Fitzgerald, a retired headteacher not easily intimidated, asked me, very politely, whether she had been the patient they were talking about. I tell the story not to shame anyone, for the team was courteous and the plan was sound, but because courtesy and inclusion are not the same thing, and a round can easily have the first without the second. None of this is rudeness; it is architecture. Hospitals pay lip service to the multidisciplinary team, yet the layout of a round tells another story. The doctors stand closest to the bed and the nurses furthest from it, and whoever speaks first sets the register for everyone who follows. What the nurses hold back are the half-formed observations: the patient who is not quite himself, the dressing that does not look right. These are hard to put into words, and doctors absorbed in the results and the plan are seldom listening for them. Students learn within a fortnight that to speak unasked is to risk seeming presumptuous. Nurses who sense this do not insist. They wait to be asked, and are rarely asked. I am not asking for a revolution, or for a longer round, or for the consultant to surrender the trolley. On my own ward the round now begins at the bed of whichever patient had the worst night, and the first question goes to the nurse who was there. Nobody announced the change and nobody has asked us to stop. I mention it only because it cost nothing, and because the rest of the semicircle needed about a week to learn where to look. The sister on the next ward has copied the idea without asking permission, which I take to be the sincerest form of audit. Harriet Pemberton is a ward sister on the medical wards at Oldtown Hospital and leads its communication programme for newly qualified nurses.
1

According to the first paragraph, what did the audit of 120 rounds show?

2

What does Rhys Jovanovic's remark about the bleep suggest?

3

The writer's attitude to Dr Kowalski's objection in the third paragraph is that it

4

What does the writer report about the huddle trial in the fourth paragraph?

5

What point does the writer make with the example of Mrs Fitzgerald?

6

In the sixth paragraph, the expression 'pay lip service to' is used to suggest that hospitals

7

In the sixth paragraph, 'them' in 'listening for them' refers to

8

What does the writer imply in the final paragraph?

Automated checks: item counts, answer keys, timing, and drug dose and unit style. — OET-READING-C-01

Answered 0 / 8